Choosing between Polyurethane Foam, Memory Foam and Latex Foam (2024)

Polyurethane foam, memory foam and latex foam are the three most common types of foam used in mattresses. While latex foam has seen a bit of a resurgence in recent years, most mattresses only contain memory foam and polyurethane foam. Interestingly, latex foam was very commonly used in mattresses prior to the introduction of polyurethane foam in the 1950’s.

We get a lot of questions about why we offer latex foam products but not offer polyurethane foam or memory foam products. We only sell latex foam products because we have a strong belief that latex foam is the best type of foam to use in mattresses and mattress toppers. Latex foam offers several significant advantages over memory foam and polyurethane foam.

Latex Foam

Latex foam is a foam produced by vulcanizing liquid latex into a solid foam. The vulcanization process cross links latex particles with sulfur through the application of heat and accelerators such as zinc oxide. Latex foam can be produced with natural latex, which is harvested from rubber trees or synthetic latex, which is produced from petrochemicals. All of the latex foam we sell contains only natural latex and never contains any synthetic latex.

Latex foam provides exact pinpointed support and reacts instantly to your every move. Latex foam does not “sink in” and “bottom out” as the night goes by. It maintains constant support and does not get softer when warmer. This makes it extremely easy to move throughout the night without any sleep interruption. The pinpointed, contoured support allows certain areas of the body to sink further into the mattress while others are supported. This is especially helpful to side sleepers, as they require more give in their shoulder and hip but more support in their midsection.

Latex foam is one of the most durable types of foam available. Latex mattresses and mattress toppers long outlast those made with memory foam and polyurethane foam. We often hear stories from customers that have had latex mattresses last over 20 years. Latex foam scores highly on all foam durability tests which simulate long periods of use.

It is very common for natural latex foam to have emissions certifications. All of the foam used in our Pure Green 100% natural latex mattresses and 100% natural latex toppers is ecoInstitut and Oeko-tex class 1 (their most stringent class) certified. While synthetic latex foam can sometimes have certifications, it is not as common.

Polyurethane Foam

Polyurethane Foam (also known as poly-foam) is the least expensive and lowest quality foam used in mattresses and mattress toppers. People are often familiar with polyurethane foam as the type of foam used in sofa cushions or cheap “egg crate” mattress toppers. Polyurethane foam is made up primarily of compounds derived from petrochemicals.

Many mattress manufacturers use polyurethane foam as the top layer of spring mattresses. This is done primarily because polyurethane is very inexpensive, not because it is high quality. More recently, many online mattress retailers have begun using polyurethane foam as a base layer in their mattresses instead of using spring coils. Polyurethane foam can be compressed very easily due to it’s low density. This allows many online mattress retailers to save on shipping cost but also causes many of these mattresses to have short lifespans.

There are several different varieties and densities of polyurethane foam. Generally, higher density polyurethane foam is a bit more durable while low-density polyurethane foam can degrade very quickly (sometimes within a year). Even high density polyurethane foam is less dense than latex foam or memory foam. All polyurethane foam, no matter what density, will degrade faster than any latex foam of decent quality.

Polyurethane foam can add some softness and support, but it will not provide the same pinpointed support associated with memory foam or latex foam. Polyurethane foam tends to collapse much quicker when pressure is applied. Because of this, it does not provide the same pinpointed, contoured support that latex foam is known for.

Polyurethane foam rarely carries any emission certifications other than the certipur-US certification. This certification is often touted by mattress manufacturers. While the certipur-US certification is certainly a step in the right direction for the polyurethane foam industry, it lacks the credibility of the third party certifications such as ecoInsitut or Oeko-tex. It is a standard that was designed and is administered by the polyurethane industry itself. While the certipur-US certification does ban the use of certain types of fire retardant chemicals, it is very common for polyurethane foam to contain fire retardant additives.

Memory Foam

Memory foam (also known as viscoelastic polyurethane foam or tempurpedic foam) is a type of polyurethane foam that contains added compounds which change the way it feels. This gives it the "slow moving" properties that memory foam is known for. For example, it will hold your handprint for a few seconds when pressed. As with polyurethane foam, memory foam is made up primarily of compounds derived from petrochemicals.

Memory foam is usually denser and more expensive than regular polyurethane foam. Memory foam does provide much a more pinpointed feel than polyurethane foam. While it provides a pinpointed feel, it is not as supportive as latex foam. We commonly talk to people who have a memory foam mattress or topper but cannot stand the unsupportive, sinking feeling they experience on it. Covering memory foam is actually one of the top reasons that people buy our mattress toppers. Unlike latex foam, which responds instantly and provides constant support, memory foam responds slowly and sinks further the longer that pressure is applied to it. The sinking of memory foam makes moving during sleep more necessary, but the slow response of the foam makes it very difficult to move without sleep being disturbed.

Memory foam is also heat reactive, which means it absorbs heat and softens as it gets warmer. This adds to the “sinking” issues mentioned above. As the memory foam heats up from your body, it gets softer and sinks more. As your body sinks further into the foam, you get hotter. This continues until many wake up to find themselves hot and stuck in one spot of their mattress. Newer versions of memory foam exist, which are designed to reduce heat (often called “gel foam”). While these foams contain chemicals which make the surface of the foam feel cooler, many experience the same heat issues with gel foam.

Densities of memory foam can vary greatly. In general, higher density memory foam is more durable and of better quality. There are a lot of very inexpensive, low density memory foam toppers which are sold online. Many mattresses also contain this low density, inexpensive memory foam. Low density memory foam may work well for a few months after purchase, but it will degrade very quickly.

As with Polyurethane foam, certipur-US is typically the only certification that can is applied to Memory foam. It is very rare to find memory foam that has any other emission certification. As with polyurethane foam, memory foam is commonly made with fire retardant chemicals.

We believe in Latex Foam

We strongly believe that latex foam is, by far, the best type of foam to use in mattresses. Latex foam offers several significant advantages over Polyurethane foam and Memory foam. Because of this our products never contain any foam other than 100% natural latex foam. Because we place such a high priority on selling high quality products at fair prices, you will find that our products do not actually cost much more than others made with much lower quality materials such as memory foam and polyurethane foam.

I'm a dedicated expert in the field of mattress materials, particularly foam technologies, with a comprehensive understanding of the nuances that differentiate various types of foams. My expertise is not just theoretical; I've delved into the practical aspects, keeping abreast of industry developments and constantly updating my knowledge base. Now, let's delve into the key concepts discussed in the article about latex foam, polyurethane foam, and memory foam used in mattresses.

Latex Foam:

1. Production Process:

  • Latex foam is produced through vulcanization, involving the cross-linking of latex particles with sulfur under heat and accelerators like zinc oxide.
  • It can be derived from natural latex harvested from rubber trees or synthetic latex produced from petrochemicals.
  • The article emphasizes that the latex foam offered contains only natural latex.

2. Support and Durability:

  • Latex foam provides pinpointed support and reacts instantly to movement, maintaining constant support without sinking or bottoming out.
  • It is highlighted as one of the most durable types of foam, with anecdotes of latex mattresses lasting over 20 years.
  • Latex foam scores highly on foam durability tests, simulating long periods of use.

3. Emissions Certifications:

  • Natural latex foam commonly comes with emissions certifications such as ecoInstitut and Oeko-tex class 1, indicating compliance with stringent standards.

Polyurethane Foam:

1. Composition and Density:

  • Polyurethane foam is the least expensive and lowest quality foam, primarily derived from compounds from petrochemicals.
  • It is available in various densities, with higher density foam generally being more durable.

2. Softness and Support:

  • While polyurethane foam can add softness and support, it lacks the pinpointed support associated with memory foam or latex foam.
  • It tends to collapse quickly under pressure, not providing the contoured support of latex foam.

3. Certifications:

  • Certipur-US certification is mentioned, but the article notes it lacks the credibility of third-party certifications such as ecoInstitut or Oeko-tex.

Memory Foam:

1. Composition and Properties:

  • Memory foam, a type of polyurethane foam, contains added compounds for its distinctive "slow-moving" properties.
  • It is denser and more expensive than regular polyurethane foam.

2. Support and Heat Reactivity:

  • Memory foam provides a more pinpointed feel but is less supportive than latex foam.
  • It is heat-reactive, absorbing heat and softening as it gets warmer, potentially causing discomfort.

3. Certifications:

  • Similar to polyurethane foam, certipur-US is often the only certification applied to memory foam.

Overall Perspective:

The article strongly advocates for latex foam, citing its superior support, durability, and often stringent emissions certifications. Polyurethane foam is presented as a lower-cost, lower-quality alternative, while memory foam is acknowledged for its pinpointed feel but criticized for its potential heat-related issues and lack of support compared to latex foam. The overarching belief is that latex foam is the optimal choice for mattresses, and the company sells exclusively latex foam products based on this conviction.

Choosing between Polyurethane Foam, Memory Foam and Latex Foam (2024)

FAQs

Choosing between Polyurethane Foam, Memory Foam and Latex Foam? ›

Latex mattresses and mattress toppers long outlast those made with memory foam and polyurethane foam. We often hear stories from customers that have had latex mattresses last over 20 years. Latex foam scores highly on all foam durability tests which simulate long periods of use.

What are the disadvantages of a PU foam mattress? ›

Poor support for spine or body - polyurethane foam does not support the body or spine properly. Not particularly comfortable - a polyurethane mattress does not feel especially comfortable. The high resiliency grade does a better job, but even then it does not match a latex mattress.

Is memory foam better than polyurethane foam? ›

It can be hard to know the answer. Poly foam is known for its balanced feel and good cooling performance, compared to memory foam. While memory foam has deeper hug, contour, and a denser feel. If you like sinking into your mattress or feeling that hug, memory foam is a great option.

Which is the best foam for a mattress? ›

Latex foam mattresses are more natural and breathable and provide good support and pressure relief. Polyfoam mattresses are less expensive than memory foam and latex foam, but may not provide the same level of pressure relief.

What are the pros and cons of latex vs memory foam? ›

The Primary Difference Between Latex vs Memory Foam Mattress
Latex MattressMemory Foam Mattress
It is resistant to dust mites, mould, and mildew.It can attract dust mites and other allergens.
It is durable and can last up to 20 years.It can last up to 10 years.
It can be more expensive.It can be less expensive.
4 more rows
May 23, 2023

What are the issues with polyurethane foam? ›

Polyurethane foam commonly contains the neurotoxin toluene and the catalyst dibutylin. These can off-gas or end up in dust from polyurethane foam. Dibutylin is a source of organotins, high concentrations of which are associated with growth abnormalities in mussels and oysters and mass mortalities of marine mammals.

Is polyurethane foam bad to sleep on? ›

The polyurethane foam in many mattresses emits potentially harmful volatile organic compounds, or VOCs, sometimes for years. Exposure to some VOCs can cause respiratory irritation, trigger asthma symptoms and, over the long term, increase the risk of cancer.

Is polyurethane memory foam better than latex? ›

All polyurethane foam, no matter what density, will degrade faster than any latex foam of decent quality. Polyurethane foam can add some softness and support, but it will not provide the same pinpointed support associated with memory foam or latex foam.

What are the pros and cons of polyurethane foam mattresses? ›

Polyurethane foam's versatility, comfort, and durability make it a popular choice for a wide range of applications. However, potential concerns such as off-gassing, heat retention, environmental impact, and firmness should also be considered.

Which is better latex foam or memory foam? ›

Latex foam is the best option for those looking for a mattress that's eco-friendly, has more bounce, and a faster response time. Memory foam is better for sleepers who want deep compression support, a slower response time, and motion isolation.

How do I choose foam? ›

Choosing a foam depends primarily on personal preference, but firmness plays a huge factor in that. HD36 foam is often used where more comfort is desired, but for a firmer, more stable support, Lux is preferred. For back cushions, the recommendation is typically a softer foam, such as Super Soft.

Which foam is best for back pain? ›

Comparison Table
Product NameMaterialPrice
Wakefit Latex MattressNatural latexRs. 20,000
Sleepyhead Orthopedic MattressHigh-density foamRs. 12,000
SleepyCat Memory Foam MattressMemory foam with cooling gelRs. 18,000
Duroflex Livein MattressAnti-microbial fabricRs. 14,000
6 more rows
Mar 18, 2024

Can bed bugs live in a foam mattress? ›

Can Bed Bugs Live On Foam Mattresses? Bed bugs can also live on memory foam mattresses. Although memory foam protects against dust and dust mites thanks to its compact construction, bed bugs tend to live on the surface, on the underside and edges of the mattress.

Why latex over memory foam? ›

Sleeper Body Type

Memory foam's tendency to allow the body to sink in is generally a good thing, though for heavier sleepers, the foam may have too much give, resulting in a less supportive feel. Latex tends to perform better for heavier sleepers.

Why is latex more expensive than memory foam? ›

This is the result of the harvesting and manufacturing process, which is far more involved than memory foam or man-made latex. It is worth reminding, though, that the price includes more longevity, plus other benefits like being hypoallergenic, and they are also safe to use for sleepers with latex allergies.

What is the disadvantage of memory foam? ›

Retain Heat: The main drawback of these mattresses is the heat retention problem. The traditional memory foam without technological add-ons tends to get very hot through the night and may become uncomfortable. Retain Moisture: The moisture retention drawback of raw memory foam is another disadvantage.

Is polyurethane mattress good or bad? ›

Poor support for spine or body - polyurethane foam does not support the body or spine properly. Not particularly comfortable - a polyurethane mattress does not feel especially comfortable. The high resiliency grade does a better job, but even then it does not match a latex mattress.

What is the life expectancy of PU foam? ›

Polyurethane rigid foam has a useful life of 50 years and more, and maintains its very low conductivity over time, due to its closed cell structure and ability to withstand external impacts such as moisture ingress or air movement.

How long does a polyurethane foam mattress last? ›

Density is the main factor that will determine how long a foam mattresses will last. A high density (2lb per cubic ft) polyurethane foam mattress has an average lifespan of 7-10 years based on a 6" thick slab.

How long does PU foam last? ›

PU foam underlay: made using recycled materials and offcuts, PU foam underlay is lightweight, environmentally friendly and the most popular option on the market. It can last up to 20 years but you'll often see performance degrade around the 10- to 15-year mark, depending on the quality of the product.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Merrill Bechtelar CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 5535

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Merrill Bechtelar CPA

Birthday: 1996-05-19

Address: Apt. 114 873 White Lodge, Libbyfurt, CA 93006

Phone: +5983010455207

Job: Legacy Representative

Hobby: Blacksmithing, Urban exploration, Sudoku, Slacklining, Creative writing, Community, Letterboxing

Introduction: My name is Merrill Bechtelar CPA, I am a clean, agreeable, glorious, magnificent, witty, enchanting, comfortable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.