What differentiates one rigid foam insulation from another? – Insulfoam (2024)

ASK THE EXPERT: What differentiates one rigid foam insulation from another?

  • Simple ways to make sure your garage isn’t costing you money on utility bills
  • A Park with Soil?

Posted by Insulfoam EPS on September 10, 2014 in Below Grade Insulation, Insulfoam In the News, Roof Insulation, Wall Insulation

0 Comments

Originally posted inAmerican School & Hospital Facilitye-Newsletter, July 2014“Ask the Expert”

Q: What differentiates one rigid foam insulation from another? Building design and construction professionals can select from several rigid foam insulations, all of which perform well in helping buildings retain or keep out heat. Yet, there are important factors to consider when evaluating some of the primary rigid foam products, like expanded polystyrene (EPS), extruded polystyrene (XPS) and polyisocyanurate (polyiso). Beyond product chemistry and manufacturing methods, two of the key differences among these materials are:

  • Insulating performance per unit of measure, and
  • Long-term thermal resistance (LTTR).

Insulating performance per unit of measure A common way to compare various insulations is R-value per inch. While such a figure demonstrates a material’s physical ability to impede heat transfer, it is of limited use when specifying insulation since performance vs. cost is the real driver in many architectural product decisions. To use a cliché, “what’s the bang for the buck?” If one looks at the R-value obtained per dollar spent, EPS rates highest. This property becomes more important once designers realize that insulation suffers from the ‘law of diminishing returns’ – additional insulation, beyond a design optimum, results in a very small net increases in energy savings.

Long-term thermal resistance (LTTR) Specifiers often focus on an insulation’s published R-value, yet might not realize that this figure is theinitialvalue at time of manufacture. Many insulations are subject to R-value degradation over the product’s time in service. This is crucial as a drop in performance over time means higher heating and cooling costs over the life of the building. EPS is one of the few rigid foam insulations with a stable thermal resistance throughout its life. In other words, the published R-value of EPS does not decrease over time, compared to other rigid insulations that typically lose up to 20% or more of their insulating capacity during time in service. The reason some rigid foams have declining R values is they use blowing agents that enhance the initial R-value, but diffuse over time and are replaced with air. A simple way to check for this is to review product warranties, which will confirm a stable or declining R-Value over time. EPS manufacturers warrant a stable R-value.

Other factors The degree to which an insulation absorbs water impacts its thermal performance. Compared to some other insulations, rigid foams as a class resist moisture well. However, one misconception is that EPS readily absorbs moisture. However, when one considers that the material is commonly used in food packaging, it’s clear that moisture absorption is actually quite low. This has been demonstrated in real-world and laboratory tests comparing moisture absorption rates. For example, side-by-side testing of EPS and XPS as below grade insulation on a building foundation in St. Paul, Minnesota, showed that EPS outperformed XPS. When the two insulations were removed after being buried under soil for 15 years, the EPS had 4.8% moisture content by volume compared to 18.9% for the XPS. After 30 days of drying time, the EPS moisture level dropped to 0.7%, while the XPS continued to hold 15.7% moisture. These days, design professionals are focusing more on the ‘life-cycle’ effect of moisture on insulation, namely the ability of an insulation to not only resist moisture, but also to readily release any moisture it absorbs. Over dry/moist cycles that grade-application insulations are commonly subjected to, EPS has shown to be the most optimum performing, through its ability to retain the least amount of moisture among rigid insulations. This helps EPS provide a higher R-value over moist-dry cycles that characterize below-grade applications.

Product make-up and applications EPS, XPS and polyiso can all be used throughout the building envelope – roofs, walls and below-grade – in buildings of all sizes and types. The three insulations are recognized as follows:

  • EPS is typically white and comes in blocks and panels of various sizes and can be faced or unfazed. Facers enhance physical properties like R-value, fire and moisture protection
  • XPS products are commonly offered as pastel or primary colored foams, depending on the brand. The product is most commonly available as board stock of fixed size and thickness.
  • Polyiso insulation panels are comprised of foam sandwiched between two facers.

Cost-saving insulation approaches As with other commercial and institutional buildings, in healthcare and educational facilities project teams can minimize rigid foam insulation material and labor costs through careful product specification. Following are two simple ways to help keep insulation costs down.

Better targeting of compressive strength

Insulation manufacturers sometimes market high compressive strength to distinguish their products. As a result, rigid foam insulation is often over-engineered in under-slab and roof applications. Readily available EPS options run up to 60 psi in compressive strength, and are strong enough for almost all building envelop applications. A testimony to EPS’s compressive strength is its use in applications in roadways and structural earthworks as geofoam, which are specified under ASTM D6817 with tighter tolerances than traditional below-grade insulation applications. The cost of using a higher strength insulation than the application requires, can be substantial. For example, specifying a 100 psi XPS product in a below-grade application when a 40 psi EPS product would suffice, can almost double the material cost.

Simplified installation with tapered roof blocks

Building professionals often create positive slopes on flat roof deck assemblies using insulation. Because they are only available in relatively thin sheets, most rigid foam insulations require stacking several layers to build up the desired slope, costing a lot of labor time and material. EPS, on the other hand, is available in individual tapered panels up to 40 inches thick. Some manufacturers have the ability to pre-cut EPS blocks into any slope 1/16 inch or greater and in virtually any custom shape to accommodate roof crickets, saddles, valleys, and ridges, along with all types of drainage systems and layouts. Since fewer separate pieces are needed, building up a slope with tapered EPS blocks requires less on-site material handling and cutting and thus installs much faster. Using tapered EPS can reduce roof insulation costs up to 30% compared to other rigid foam products.

Composite insulation

EPS and polyiso are commonly used in many roofing assemblies, and now manufacturers are producing composite panels that combine these two materials. The EPS provides a lightweight, insulating and resilient foam insulation, while the polyiso serves as an insulating cover board for enhanced durability. Some composite products, such as the InsulFoam® HD Composite panel, carry a UL Class A fire rating for both combustible and non-combustible decks, and are compatible with a range of roofing membranes – including EPDM, TPO, PVC, CSPE, and low-sloped, built-up and modified bitumen membrane systems. As many low-rise healthcare facilities and some schools have wood roof decks, such rated products provide an easy-to-install insulation for fire-rated assemblies.

EPS QUESTIONS?

ContactRam Mayilvahanan,Insulfoam’s Product-Marketing Manager

[emailprotected]

Read more on Insulfoam.com

Tags:EPS manufacturers, EPS outperformed XPS, EPS vs XPS, Long-term thermal resistance, moisture in insulation, rigid foam insulation

What differentiates one rigid foam insulation from another? – Insulfoam (2)

About Insulfoam EPS

0 Comments

Leave a reply

What differentiates one rigid foam insulation from another? – Insulfoam (2024)

FAQs

What is the best rigid foam insulation? ›

The best kind of rigid foam insulation is polyisocyanurate, also known as polyiso. It has the highest R-rating of any rigid foam insulation and comes with a reflective foil on both sides, allowing it to act as a radiant barrier as well.

What is rigid foam insulation? ›

Rigid foam sheathing is a form of insulation — continuous insulation, to be exact — that's applied to the exterior of the building. Continuous rigid insulation is a construction solution that provides a thermally efficient building enclosure.

What are the different types of foam board? ›

When building or renovating a high-performance building envelope there are really three main kinds of rigid foam panels you are going to have to choose from - Polyisocyanurate known as Polyiso (PIR), Extruded Polystyrene (XPS) - often called Styrofoam - and Expanded Polystyrene (EPS).

What is the thickest rigid foam insulation? ›

How Thick Is Rigid Foam Insulation Board? Rigid board insulation generally comes in standard thicknesses ranging from ½ inch to 2 inches. It is possible for homes located in extreme climates to order specialty thicknesses of up to 6 inches directly from certain manufacturers.

Can rigid foam insulation get wet? ›

Homes with open cell spray foam don't have to replace the foam when it gets wet, or even after it has been submerged. This might come as a surprise because there is a common misconception that all open cell spray foams absorb water like a sponge and retain it, but that's not the case.

What is the thinnest insulation with highest R-value? ›

Thermablok® Aerogel is a revolutionary advancement in thermal technology offering the thinnest insulation available to prevent thermal and cold bridging. Classed as a Super Insulation, Aerogel has the highest insulation value of any known material with the lowest thermal conductivity value of any solid (0.015W/mK).

Does rigid foam lose R-value? ›

Extruded Polystyrene (XPS)

A popular rigid insulation choice, XPS features an initial R-value of R-5 per inch. That said, the long term R-values of this foam board decline over time. For example, after just 5 years, an XPS board will see its R-value fall by 10%, and even more going forward.

What is rigid foam insulation made of? ›

Foam board insulation are rigid panels of insulation that are made of either polystyrene, polyisocyanurate, and polyurethane, according to the U.S. Department of Energy.

Can you put rigid foam insulation in inside walls? ›

Rigid foam board insulation can be used throughout the home, but most often it is found in basem*nt walls. If you are a do-it-yourself homeowner finishing your basem*nt, you might decide to use foam board insulation on the walls behind the studs. This is standard for most basem*nt walls.

How strong is rigid foam? ›

As a result, rigid foam insulation is often over-engineered in under-slab and roof applications. Readily available EPS options run up to 60 psi in compressive strength, and are strong enough for almost all building envelop applications.

What are three different types of foam? ›

Polyurethane foam, memory foam and latex foam are the three most common types of foam used in mattresses.

What are the two types of foam? ›

The two most used foam types in reusable packaging are Polyurethane and Polyethylene foams. This is a spongy foam like the consistency of foam used in pillows or mattress covers. It is an open-cell material which means it will absorb liquids.

Which is the best quality of foam? ›

However, it is more expensive than other foam options. Used in top-of-line mattresses, Latex Rubber is an excellent quality foam. This comfort further extends to sofa cushions. Latex foam is one of the highest quality foam seat cushions that can be purchased.

What is the R-value of 2 inch rigid foam? ›

R-Value Chart for EnerfoilTM Rigid Foam Faced Insulation
Thickness (Inches)R-value (in I-P/Imperial)RSI (R-value in Metric)
1.59.31.62
2.012.42.16
2.515.52.7
3.018.63.24
6 more rows
13 Dec 2018

Can I use multiple layers of foam board insulation? ›

When two or more layers of polyiso insulation boards are used together to provide the specified insulation thickness for a commercial roof, you dramatically minimize thermal bridging. In order to create the most energy efficient installation, the joints of the polyiso insulation boards should be offset.

What is the R-value of 2 inch high density foam? ›

Because the R value of open-cell spray foam is R-3.5 to R-3.7 per inch, you'll get a total R value of R-7.0 if using two inches of foam and a total R-14.0 if you're using four. With closed-cell spray foam insulation, it will be a total of R-13.0 for two inches and R-26.0 for four.

Will mold grow on rigid foam? ›

Foam building insulation, in both spray foam and foam board products, is resistant to mold growth but as we will explain here it is not absolutely mold-roof, and on occasion we do find mold growth on the surface of even closed-cell foam, in open-celled foam (rare), and on th surface of EPS and other foam insulating ...

Can rigid foam insulation be left exposed in attic? ›

It depends on the application; it can be left exposed in an attic or crawlspace type of application. Local building codes should be reviewed for exposed interior applications. If it's an exterior application, it should be covered with some sort of finishing material.

What happens if foam insulation gets wet? ›

Open cell spray foam is very breathable. It does let moisture pass through instead of trapping it inside of the insulation itself. Your home will not fill with water though, no need to worry about that!

Does rigid foam insulation need to be covered in crawl space? ›

See the guide for installing band joist area insulation at this link. It is not necessary to apply insulation to the underside of the floor above a closed crawlspace because the rigid foam board insulation applied to the walls provides the necessary thermal protection.

Do I have to cover rigid foam insulation? ›

Tests have shown that these laminated boards can withstand UV ray damage for a reasonably long time. That said, it's still advisable to cover any foam board insulation exposed to the Sun within 30-60 days at the most. On most projects, that's more than enough time to finish the exterior walls.

Can you leave rigid insulation exposed? ›

Rigid foam insulation, whether it is expanded or extruded polystyrene, does have to be covered if it is installed in the interior of a building. This wall covering must have a minimum fire rating to protect the insulation from quick combustion during a fire.

What is the best insulation on the market? ›

The best types of home attic insulation are open cell spray foam, fiberglass, and cellulose.
  • Cellulose is the oldest insulation material used for not only the attic but other areas of the home as well. ...
  • Fiberglass is another traditional insulation material that consists of extremely fine glass fibers.
1 Jun 2020

Whats the best insulation on the market? ›

What is the most energy efficient wall insulation? Closed cell spray-foam insulation is the most energy efficient wall insulation. Applications can reach much higher R-values for each inch of thickness than other insulation products, with values as high as R-6.2 per square inch (roughly R-34 on a 2×6 wall).

What is the best rated R insulation? ›

Depending on where you live and the part of your home you're insulating (walls, crawlspace, attic, etc.), you'll need a different R-Value. Typical recommendations for exterior walls are R-13 to R-23, while R-30, R-38 and R-49 are common for ceilings and attic spaces.

Is rigid foam board a vapor barrier? ›

Rigid foam board, especially foil-faced polyisocyanurate, creates a vapor-impermeable barrier, so the wall would have limited drying potential. Even more permeable types of insulation, such as expanded polystyrene, are vapor barriers when the installation is thick enough.

Does stacking insulation increase R-value? ›

The thermal barrier of a home should consist of a continuous layer of insulation on all sides—including the lowest floor, the exterior walls, and the ceiling or roof. Doubling the thickness of insulation will double the insulation's R-value, cutting heat loss in half.

How much weight can rigid foam support? ›

ASTM C578 standard for EPS type I is 10psi or 1,440 pounds per square ft (1 square foot is equal to 144 square inches). One square inch of Type I EPS can support 10 pounds; however, set a one square foot board on the foam and it can support 1,440 pounds.

What is the difference between extruded and expanded foam rigid insulation panels? ›

XPS is manufactured in a continuous extrusion process that produces a closed cell form of foam insulation. EPS, on the other hand, is manufactured by expanding spherical beads in a mold and then using heat and pressure to fuse the beads together. Each product has proponents claiming one out performs the other.

Who makes rigid foam insulation? ›

Owens Corning® FOAMULAR® & FOAMULAR® NGX™ 250 Extruded Polystyrene (XPS) Rigid Foam Insulation is a closed cell, highly moisture-resistant foam board well suited to meet the insulation needs for a wide variety of residential and commercial building applications.

Does foam board need thermal barrier? ›

1.14. A thermal barrier is not required for foam plastic installed in a masonry or concrete wall, floor or roof system where the foam plastic insulation is covered on each face by not less than 1-inch (25 mm) thickness of masonry or concrete.

Can you put rigid foam over drywall? ›

A: I recommend keeping your work process as simple and clean as possible, and rigid foam can certainly help you achieve this. Install 1 1/2-inch- or two-inch-thick sheets right over existing drywall wall surfaces (held in place with a few dabs of construction adhesive), then put new drywall on top.

How thick should my foam board insulation be? ›

Now generically speaking, we usually recommend open cell spray foam to be 6- to 10-inches on a roof deck or ceiling and 3-inches in the walls. Closed cell spray foam should be 4- to 5- inches on the ceiling and 2- to 3-inches in the walls.

Can you bend rigid foam insulation? ›

You can bend flat sheets of Styrofoam into any shape you need. Styrofoam, which is also known as polystyrene, is a hard foam material often used in building props and models. The foam is used as a "core," or inside piece, for a fiberglass or other plastic coating.

What is the R-value of rigid foam insulation? ›

Styrofoam is a trademark name for XPS; the R-value of Styrofoam is 5.2 per inch since it is a high-density XPS. High-density EPS has an R-value of 4.2 per inch; low-density EPS has an R-value of 3.85 per inch.

Does rigid foam expand and contract? ›

Foams, all of them, expand and contract due to temperature as do pretty much all materials.

What is the difference between Class A and Class B foam? ›

The true difference between a Class A foam and a Class B foam is that the Class B foam repels the carbons forming a film over the liquid, resulting in the suppression of the vapors, which is what is actually burning, while the Class A foam is penetrating the fuel.

How many types of foam systems are there? ›

We discussed that there are three types of foams based on the expansion ratio.

What is the best density foam? ›

High-Quality: 2.5LB – 3.5LB Density

For conventional open-cell foam, materials in this range are the best of the best.

What is Type 3 foam insulation? ›

Type 3 and Type 4 polystyrene insulation are generally extruded polystyrene. The closed-cell structure provides long-term water resistance properties and excellent mechanical properties to this foam. The cells retain a gas that provides a high thermal resistance value of R5.

What type of foam does not absorb water? ›

Dry Fast Foam

It is non-water absorbent and won't mold, rot or mildew. It is very resilient and buoyant, with an open-cell structure. Dry Fast Foam is used for filtering or padding that is subject to high amounts of liquid.

What is Type 2 foam insulation? ›

InsulFoam II Below Grade is an engineered insulation consisting of a superior closed-cell, lightweight and resilient expanded polystyrene (EPS). InsulFoam II meets or exceeds the requirements of ASTM C578, Type II, Standard Specification for Rigid, Cellular Polystyrene Thermal Insulation.

What is the strongest foam? ›

Aluminum foamed is formed by adding additives to pure aluminum or aluminum alloy through a foaming process, and has both metal and bubble characteristics.

What type of foam is heat resistant? ›

Commercial grade silicone foam is flexible light density material with smooth skin on both sides. Silicone foam is flame-retardant, self-extinguishing & can withstand 2100 degrees F flame for more than 10 minutes without burning.

What lowers the quality of the foam? ›

Addition of fat: The presence of fat interferes with foam formation and decreases the foam. Similar effect is observed when yolk is added to white. This effect is the result of the fat probably the lipoproteins, in the egg yolk which may form a complex with proteins in the white.

Which is better EPS or XPS? ›

EPS has a water vapour diffusion resistance of 30-70, whereas XPS reaches 80-250. Slightly more permeable to air and moisture, EPS is less resistant to water vapour than XPS. If you're looking to insulate a space prone to humidity (e.g. floors, cellars, and foundation walls), XPS is your best option.

What are the 5 types of insulation? ›

The most common insulation materials are fiberglass, cellulose and foam. Home insulation types include any of the above materials in the form of loose-fill, batts, rolls, foam board, spray foam and radiant barriers.

What is Type 2 rigid insulation? ›

However, Type 2 is moulded expanded polystyrene (design R4/inch) or of extruded polystyrene (design R5/inch). Type 3 and Type 4 polystyrene insulation are generally extruded polystyrene. The closed-cell structure provides long-term water resistance properties and excellent mechanical properties to this foam.

What type of foam insulation is best? ›

Closed cell foam is the best choice for robust insulating where space is an issue, as it can achieve 2x the R-Value of open cell inside a standard wall. Its rigid nature also adds to the structural integrity of the building and E84 fire rated versions are available.

Does rigid insulation need a Vapour barrier? ›

Rigid foam insulation is it's own vapour barrier in this application, so you don't need to use the poly. Just make sure you tuck tape all the joints.

What is the R-value of 2 inch foam board? ›

You can check this chart and see that a 2-inch ISO foam board has an R-value of R-11.6. If you have a rigid ISO foam board that is more than 9 inches thick, you can expect that the R-value of such board will be over R-50. This is more than enough even for attics (the best attic insulation is usually R-49).

Does XPS insulation need to be covered? ›

Most interior XPS boards must be covered with an accepted thermal barrier. Some XPS products have passed the NFPA 286 testing and don't require a thermal barrier; check with your manufacturer to see which XPS products are exempt.

What thickness of insulation is best? ›

Current government recommendations are for loft insulation to achieve a depth of between 250mm and 270mm but some new properties are increasing their level of loft insulation to 300mm.

What is the best insulation to keep cold out? ›

Fiberglass Insulation

This type of insulation material is widely available and comes in various shapes and sizes. For cold climates, Loose-fill Fiberglass Insulation is the best as it has an R-Value of 60.

What is the highest rated insulation? ›

What is the most energy efficient wall insulation? Closed cell spray-foam insulation is the most energy efficient wall insulation. Applications can reach much higher R-values for each inch of thickness than other insulation products, with values as high as R-6.2 per square inch (roughly R-34 on a 2×6 wall).

What are the four types of insulation? ›

There are several different types of insulation, including the four most common listed below:
  • Loose-Fill & Blown-In Insulation.
  • Batt & Roll Insulation.
  • Reflective Insulation & Radiant Barriers.
  • Spray Foam & Foam-In-Place Insulation.
15 May 2018

What is the cheapest rigid insulation? ›

Expanded polystyrene, also referred to as EPS, white board, and bead board, has the lowest R-value of the three rigid foam board insulation types, but is the most economical and versatile.

What is the thinnest insulation with the highest R-value? ›

Thermablok® Aerogel is a revolutionary advancement in thermal technology offering the thinnest insulation available to prevent thermal and cold bridging. Classed as a Super Insulation, Aerogel has the highest insulation value of any known material with the lowest thermal conductivity value of any solid (0.015W/mK).

What are the disadvantages of foam insulation? ›

Below we are going to list the most common problems with using spray foam insulation in your home's attic or in any area inside of your home.
  • Placement Errors During Installation. ...
  • Potentially Attracts Water Damage. ...
  • The Material May Shrink Overtime. ...
  • Long Dry and Cure Time.
4 Dec 2019

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nicola Considine CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 5843

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nicola Considine CPA

Birthday: 1993-02-26

Address: 3809 Clinton Inlet, East Aleisha, UT 46318-2392

Phone: +2681424145499

Job: Government Technician

Hobby: Calligraphy, Lego building, Worldbuilding, Shooting, Bird watching, Shopping, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Nicola Considine CPA, I am a determined, witty, powerful, brainy, open, smiling, proud person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.