Why is EMDR Therapy Controversial? - AlphaMind Counseling Centers (2024)

EMDR therapy is a trauma therapy that is sometimes considered controversial. The reasons someone might think it is a controversial therapy option are the potential adverse side effects and the lack of long-term research. EMDR is safe and effective, but there are some risks associated with the therapy. EMDR therapy benefits those who have experienced trauma, as it can help to heal the psychological wounds of trauma. EMDR is preferred over regular talk therapy for its ability to directly address the memories and emotions associated with trauma. However, not everyone is a fan of EMDR therapy. In this article, we’ll explore the reasons why EMDR is controversial and whether or not the controversy is warranted.

Why is EMDR Therapy Controversial? - AlphaMind Counseling Centers (1)

What is EMDR Therapy?

EMDR therapy was discovered nearly thirty years ago. It was found that eye movements could decrease the negative emotions that came along with certain traumatic experiences and memories. Since its discovery, EMDR therapy has evolved into a more fine-tuned treatment to create an even more effective therapy option.

With EMDR therapy, individuals have the opportunity to recognize feelings associated with the traumatic event and eventually let go of the cyclical pattern of thinking. Once this happens, the individual undergoing treatment is able to develop more positive self-beliefs.

Benefits of EMDR

EMDR is a trauma therapy that has helped many people heal from the psychological wounds of trauma. EMDR is preferred over regular talk therapy for its ability to directly address the memories and emotions associated with trauma without needing to speak about the trauma in-depth. It even works more quickly than other trauma-focused therapies, such as cognitive behavioral therapies. Additionally, it can help with your somatic symptoms that you feel in response to the trauma.

EMDR is safe and effective, but there are some side effects associated with the therapy. EMDR should only be used under the care of a trained professional in order to receive the safest and most effective results. EMDR therapy is also safe for children as a form of treatment.

Drawbacks of EMDR

EMDR has the potential for mild adverse side effects, and there is a lack of long-term research on the therapy explaining why exactly the treatment is effective. When undergoing EMDR therapy treatments, some of the side effects you may experience include: vivid dreams, heightened sensitivity to emotions and physical sensations, lightheadedness, anxiety, and headaches.

However, these side effects will typically go away after a few sessions. In fact, you are likely to feel overall improvement from your everyday symptoms after just a couple sessions.

If you experience any side effects while undergoing EMDR therapy, make sure you inform your therapist. This way, they can help you through any side effects you experience and adjust your treatment plan as necessary.

Controversy

EMDR is a trauma therapy that has helped many people heal from the psychological wounds of trauma. The therapy is safe and effective, but there are some side effects associated with it. EMDR is controversial because of these potential risks and supposed lack of research, but the controversy may be unwarranted. EMDR has helped many people heal from trauma, and it is preferred over regular talk therapy for its ability to directly address the memories and emotions associated with trauma.

Other reasons individuals may consider EMDR therapy controversial is that they do not believe it is actually helping patients heal from their trauma – they believe that EMDR is simply a form of disassociating from the trauma that occured. Others worry, despite the proven benefits, that EMDR will actually have the opposite effect. They believe that there is a chance for EMDR to make the symptoms permanently worse.

Much of the controversy surrounding EMDR therapy stems from lack of knowledge and understanding of what is actually happening during treatment.

Who it helps

EMDR therapy has been proven to help individuals with a variety of different conditions. However, EMDR therapy is most widely known to help individuals who suffer from the effects of trauma and PTSD. Some symptoms of this may look like anxiety, panic, depression, feeling stuck, and nightmares. Dealing with these symptoms may decrease the quality of someone’s day-to-day life and make it feel difficult to complete what used to be considered a basic task for them. Other conditions that EMDR can help with include bipolar disorder, psychosis, anxiety disorders, substance abuse, and eating disorders.

Conclusion

As you can see, while EMDR therapy often draws a lot of controversy to it, it is a safe and effective therapy treatment for individuals with various different conditions. Here at AlphaMind Brain Centers, we work diligently to provide all of our patients with the best treatment option for them; no two individuals will have the same treatment plan. Want to get an idea of what your treatment plan would be and live near the Cary, North Carolina area? Contact us here at AlphaMind Brain Centers! With our free consultation option, we can help you figure out what treatment is best for you and address any questions or concerns you may have. If this sounds like something you are looking for, use the contact form below or give us a call at your earliest convenience.

    Why is EMDR Therapy Controversial? - AlphaMind Counseling Centers (2024)

    FAQs

    Why is EMDR Therapy Controversial? - AlphaMind Counseling Centers? ›

    The therapy is safe and effective, but there are some side effects associated with it. EMDR is controversial because of these potential risks and supposed lack of research, but the controversy may be unwarranted.

    What is the controversy with EMDR therapy? ›

    So just why can EMDR be controversial? Tuono-Shell said there are various reasons, including questions around if EMDR is evidence based, if it will make mental health issues worse, if it's a form of hypnosis, and if it's only for treating PTSD. For example, some may think it's a hoax.

    Who is EMDR not recommended for? ›

    But if you have a condition you were born with or was passed down through your family, or you're dealing with complications from a brain injury, EMDR may not be appropriate or helpful. Also, some people who have only recently survived trauma may not yet be ready to process their experiences through EMDR.

    What are the downsides of EMDR? ›

    “There are very few side effects of EMDR therapy. The psychotherapy may cause a person to experience strong recollections of traumatic experiences which can be upsetting, and emotions may fluctuate between high a low after sessions as a person reflects upon the experience," Bolton says.

    Is EMDR brainwashing? ›

    EMDR therapy is not brainwashing or hypnosis. Patients are in complete control of the process and can stop at any time. They choose a target and notice what happens during each set of bilateral stimulation.

    Why is EMDR so draining? ›

    Feeling Tired After EMDR Therapy

    Your brain is also building new, positive neural connections. That takes a lot of energy. If you feel totally wiped, that's normal.

    Is EMDR unbiblical? ›

    In light of our biblical commitments, we conclude: EMDR is not compatible with a biblical counseling model or worldview. Scripture helps appreciate some aspects of EMDR, is neutral on others, and directly opposes core philosophical assumptions.

    Is EMDR considered controversial? ›

    EMDR therapy is a trauma therapy that is sometimes considered controversial. The reasons someone might think it is a controversial therapy option are the potential adverse side effects and the lack of long-term research. EMDR is safe and effective, but there are some risks associated with the therapy.

    Can EMDR trigger dissociation? ›

    Challenges of using EMDR for Dissociative Disorder

    “The use of eye movements too early in treatment risks premature penetration of dissociative barriers. This could produce such results as flooding of the system, uncontrolled destabilization, and increased suicidal or homicidal risk.”

    What do therapists look for during EMDR? ›

    You'll then look to discuss 'possible targets for EMDR processing. These include recent distressing events, current situations that elicit emotional disturbance, related historical incidents, and the development of specific skills and behaviours that will be needed by the client in future situations.

    What is the success rate of EMDR therapy? ›

    Some studies showed 84-90% of single event trauma victims no longer had PTSD symptoms after three ninety minute EMDR sessions. Another study showed 100% success rate for single event trauma victims. Another study showed success with 77% of multiple trauma victims after six fifty minute sessions.

    Why does my body hurt after EMDR? ›

    These side effects may sound alarming but rest assured that they are completely normal. You would expect to feel some pain or swelling around an injury on your body as it heals — these side effects just indicate that your brain is reprocessing and healing too.

    Is EMDR therapy credible? ›

    Effectiveness and Efficiency: Evidence-based studies affirm EMDR's rapid and effective treatment outcomes for PTSD. Global Recognition: Endorsem*nts from major health organizations bolster EMDR's credibility as a frontline treatment for PTSD.

    Can EMDR trigger psychosis? ›

    Perhaps most important to note is that EMDR did not cause any adversities. This article describes the conceptualization and application of EMDR in the treatment of psychotic symptoms and psychosis-related imagery, using the Two Method Approach.

    What is looping in EMDR? ›

    In EMDR Therapy, there is a common term referred to as "Looping". Looping is when an individual in is the middle of Phase 4 of EMDR therapy, but the processing is blocked. A client is stuck on negative thoughts or beliefs.

    Why does EMDR make me feel weird? ›

    EMDR triggers a reorganisation of your thoughts and emotions, necessitating time to integrate fully. After a session, your mind diligently works to make sense of the new insights and emotional releases, contributing to the sense of weirdness.

    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Article information

    Author: Ray Christiansen

    Last Updated:

    Views: 5991

    Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

    Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Ray Christiansen

    Birthday: 1998-05-04

    Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

    Phone: +337636892828

    Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

    Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

    Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.